Idaho Bluegrass Association
  • Home
    • About
    • Join Us
    • Donate
    • IBA Newsletter
    • Our Logo
  • Articles & Podcasts
    • Podcasts >
      • ​Jeremy Garrett Interview
      • Keith Reed Interview
      • Jason Homey Interview
      • Becky Smith Interview
      • Marv Quinton Interview
      • Rue Frisbee Interview
      • Donna and Mike Bond Interview
      • Honi Deaton Interview
      • Dennis Stokes Interview
      • Gary Eller Interview
    • Articles >
      • Glen Garrett - The Golden Years
      • Sammie Bush - came to Weiser
      • Mark O’Connor - My History at Weiser
      • Barbara Lamb - Fiddler Extraordinaire
      • Charlie Simmons -The Idaho Bluegrass Association from 1975 to 1985
      • Idaho's 19th century Fiddlers
      • Weiser Fiddle Champions ​ 1950s & 1960s
      • ​Byron Berline
      • Dave Frisbee
      • Weiser Fiddle Champions from 1970s and 80s
      • Megan Lynch Chowning
      • Fiddle Champion ​in 1990s and 2000s
      • Tashina and Tristan Clarridge
    • Snap Shot - Videos from IBA members
  • Events
    • Calendar (BCBB)
    • Open Mic
    • SpringGrass 2023 >
      • Springfest 2022
    • Winterfest
    • IBA Concert Series
    • Virtualgrass
    • Other Bluegrass Events
  • Jam
    • Idaho Jams
    • Jason's Beginner Jam Blog 2021 - 2022
    • Jason's Intermediate Jam Blog 2021 - 2022
    • All of Jason's Songs
    • Old Blogs from Jason >
      • Jason's Beginner Jam Blog 2019 - 2021
      • Jason's Intermediate Jam Blog 2019 - 2021
      • Jason's Beginner Jam Blog 2017 - 2018
      • Jason's Intermediate Jam Blog 2017 - 2018
      • Songs in 2016
  • Camps & Contests
    • Idaho Bluegrass and Banjo Camp
    • Banjo Contest
    • National Oldtime Fiddlers’ Contest
  • Idaho Bands
  • Teachers
  • Classified
  • Links
    • General
    • Learning
    • Specific Instruments

Why Don't You Tell Me So

9/24/2018

0 Comments

 
Hi,
The song of the week is the Flatt & Scruggs classic 'Why Don't You Tell Me So' in the key of F.

Recordings
Here is the original Flatt & Scruggs recording of Why Don't You Tell Me So - key of F#
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72MGGsdf7L0

Here is a good cover version of the song from Tony Rice - key of F
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tgTiqz2X1Mg&list=PLJcseQaUtw9WQvE_F-tmDHRwhKTfOr6iz&index=5

Tuning
The Flatt & Scruggs recording is in the very rarely used key of F# (or Gb, if you prefer) instead of the much more common key of F only because the instruments were all tuned a half step higher in pitch than standard. To play along with the recording, I advise banjo, mandolin and fiddle players to tune their instruments a half step higher and then play as if in F. (Guitar players need not retune their instruments, for there is little advantage in doing so: either capo 4 and then play as if in D, capo 6 and then play as if in C, or capo 2 and then play as if in E will work just fine for playing along with the recording.)

Note to Banjo Players
If the band had been tuned to standard pitch, Scruggs' playing on Why Don't You Tell Me So would be an example of playing in F without a capo (banjo tuned in G tuning with the 5th string capoed at the 7th fret so that the 5th string registers as an A note, a note that is part of the F chord).

For banjo players who wish to learn Earl's backup parts and break from the record, I point out that there is little difference in how it feels to play Scruggs' parts out of G (tuned down a half step from G tuning to be in tune with the recording: F#,C#,F#,A#,C#), or out of F (tuned up a half step from G tuning, with the 5th string capoed at the 7th fret: A#,D#,G#,B#,D#.  B#=C) since only in a couple of spots in his backup playing does Scruggs use an open string, and in his break, the only open string he makes use of is the 5th string. Scruggs' playing on Why Don't You Tell Me So consists almost entirely of the same types of licks that he used in his key of G playing on other songs, just moved down two frets lower to put his playing in the key of F. There are however, a couple of spots during the backup parts in which one will run out of frets if tuned down instead of tuned up, but an easy fix for this is to simply drop those spots a whole octave: i.e., play the notes 12 frets lower.

For the sake of banjo players who have little or no experience playing the kinds of movable licks that Scruggs used on the recording, and little or no experience with playing in the key of F without a capo, I suggest going with the capo 5 and then play as if in C option for playing in the key of F on this song.
In the attachments, I have included two banjo tab melody sheets: one in the key of F and one in the key of C.

Finally, it should be observed that Scruggs' up the neck break that occurs after the second chorus of the song does not follow the melody closely enough to be used as an effective intro break for the song. 

Progression
The chord progression for the verses and breaks is the very familiar progression:
1111
1155
1144
1511
(Prog. V2 on the basic chord progressions chart)

The chord progression for the choruses is the most common progression for choruses in songs in which the verses use Prog. V2 while the choruses use a different progression. Only the first line differs from V2:
4411
1155
1144
1511
(Prog. X2)

The Mercury Sessions
Why Don't You Tell Me So was the 8th song that Flatt & Scruggs recorded together after leaving Bill Monroe's band. It is one of 28 songs that Flatt & Scruggs recorded together on Mercury Records between 1948 and 1950 (before they went to a different record label: Columbia). This collection of 28 songs is commonly referred to as 'the Mercury Sessions', and I consider it to be essential listening for students of Bluegrass music. 

Most of these 28 songs have become Bluegrass standards and have been covered by numerous Bluegrass artists.

In the order in which they were recorded, here are youtube links to the 28 songs of the Mercury Sessions. Songs that I especially recommend listening to several times over are marked with an asterisk

*1. We'll Meet Again Sweetheart
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X3RcgwB6KU0

2. God Loves His Children
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEBnwo4Ib1k

*3. My Cabin In Caroline
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S2pgJPPbpPg

4. I'm Going To Make Heaven My Home
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6KkvX1Ovzqw

5. Baby Blue Eyes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lWUg88uAwec

*6. Down The Road
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q40vZj20E4I

7. Bouquet In Heaven
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukuGbljTHTc

*8. Why Don't You Tell Me So
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72MGGsdf7L0

*9. I'll Never Shed Another Tear
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRaYfXow3C8

*10. Foggy Mountain Breakdown
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_Y3mnj-8lA

*11. No Mother Or Dad
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPkNgMdqbWE

*12. Is It Too Late Now
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DTlBvA2mpxY

*13. My Little Girl In Tennessee
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MSou2EEiTQ

14. I'll Be Going To Heaven Sometime
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkKK4KeolyQ

15. I'll Never Love Another
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=enZQBRDkQQU

16. So Happy I'll Be
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqDD_KvbjoA

*17. Doin' My Time
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMdYyoF_uOM

*18. Pike County Breakdown
 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjKthlpnP-o

19. Preachin' Prayin' Singin'
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xxa44eER4g

*20. Cora Is Gone
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vtLYK1aWNw

*21. Pain In My Heart
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blG497HwaQE

*22. Roll In My Sweet Baby's Arms
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=riHYkRKXydU

23. Back To The Cross
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7zuog7ra1-Y

*24. Old Salty Dog Blues 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ms2IOc_HA4E

25. Will The Roses Bloom (Where She Lies Sleeping)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgqTLm35j4c

*26. Take Me In A LIfeboat
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtCZPhsfAtI

*27. Farewell Blues
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m259Pg25wdY

28. I'll Just Pretend
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0h8IB33hUfY

Farewell Blues
The third line of the progression for Farewell Blues is: 6 6 2 b3.
In the key of D, that is: BBEF (B7 may be used in place of B). In the key of C, that is: AADEb.

Rocky Top
The progression for the chorus of Rocky Top is:
6m 6m 5  5
b7  b7  4  4
4    4    1  1
1    b7  1  1
1    b7  1  1

Happy Pickin',
Jason
Why Don't You Tell Me So - banjo tab (C)
File Size: 442 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - banjo tab (F)
File Size: 440 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - guitar tab (C)
File Size: 445 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - guitar tab (D)
File Size: 452 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - mandolin tab (F)
File Size: 365 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - melody in F
File Size: 442 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

0 Comments

Why Don't You Tell Me So

10/14/2017

0 Comments

 
Hi,
The song of the week is the Flatt & Scruggs classic 'Why Don't You Tell Me So' in the key of G.

Recordings
Here is the original Flatt & Scruggs recording of Why Don't You Tell Me So - key of F#
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72MGGsdf7L0

Here is a good cover version of the song from Tony Rice - key of F
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tgTiqz2X1Mg&list=PLJcseQaUtw9WQvE_F-tmDHRwhKTfOr6iz&index=5

Tuning
The Flatt & Scruggs recording is in the very rarely used key of F# (or Gb, if you prefer) instead of the much more common key of F only because the instruments were all tuned a half step higher in pitch than standard. To play along with the recording, I advise banjo, mandolin and fiddle players to either tune their instruments a half step higher and then play as if in F, or to tune their instruments a half step lower and then play as if in G. (Guitar players need not retune their instruments, for there is little advantage in doing so: either capo 4, and then play as if in D, or capo 2 and then play as if in E will work just fine for playing along with the recording.)

Note to Banjo Players
If the band had been tuned to standard pitch, Scruggs' playing on Why Don't You Tell Me So would be an example of playing in F without a capo (banjo tuned in G tuning with the 5th string capoed at the 7th fret so that the 5th string registers as an A note, a note that is part of the F chord).

For banjo players who wish to learn Earl's backup parts and break from the record, I point out that there is little difference in how it feels to play Scruggs' parts out of G (tuned down a half step from G tuning to be in tune with the recording: F#,C#,F#,A#,C#), or out of F (tuned up a half step from G tuning, with the 5th string capoed at the 7th fret: A#,D#,G#,B#,D#.  B#=C) since only in a couple of spots in his backup playing does Scruggs use an open string, and in his break, the only open string he makes use of is the 5th string. There are however, a couple of spots during the backup parts in which one will run out of frets if tuned down instead of tuned up, but an easy fix for this is to simply drop those spots a whole octave: i.e., play the notes 12 frets lower.

For banjo players who have little or no experience playing up the neck (besides vamping), I recommend working up down-the-neck breaks and backup parts out of G with the help of banjo tab melody sheet in the attachments. 

Finally, it should be observed that Scruggs' up the neck break that occurs after the second chorus of the song does not follow the melody closely enough to be used as an effective intro break for the song.

Progression
The chord progression for the verses and breaks is the very familiar progression:

1111
1155
1144
1511
(Prog. V2 on the basic chord progressions chart)

The chord progression for the choruses is the most common progression for choruses in songs in which the verses use Prog. V2 while the choruses use a different progression. Only the first line differs from V2:

4411
1155
1144
1511
(Prog. X2)

The Mercury Sessions
Why Don't You Tell Me So was the 8th song that Flatt & Scruggs recorded together after leaving Bill Monroe's band. It is one of 28 songs that Flatt & Scruggs recorded together on Mercury Records between 1948 and 1950 (before they went to a different record label: Columbia). This collection of 28 songs is commonly referred to as 'the Mercury Sessions', and I consider it to be essential listening for students of Bluegrass music. 

Most of these 28 songs have become Bluegrass standards and have been covered by numerous Bluegrass artists.

In the order in which they were recorded, here are youtube links to the 28 songs of the Mercury Sessions. Songs that I especially recommend listening to several times over are marked with an asterisk

*1. We'll Meet Again Sweetheart
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X3RcgwB6KU0

2. God Loves His Children
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEBnwo4Ib1k

*3. My Cabin In Caroline
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S2pgJPPbpPg

4. I'm Going To Make Heaven My Home
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6KkvX1Ovzqw

5. Baby Blue Eyes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lWUg88uAwec

*6. Down The Road
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q40vZj20E4I

7. Bouquet In Heaven
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukuGbljTHTc

*8. Why Don't You Tell Me So
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72MGGsdf7L0

*9. I'll Never Shed Another Tear
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRaYfXow3C8

*10. Foggy Mountain Breakdown
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_Y3mnj-8lA

*11. No Mother Or Dad
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPkNgMdqbWE

*12. Is It Too Late Now
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DTlBvA2mpxY

*13. My Little Girl In Tennessee
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MSou2EEiTQ

14. I'll Be Going To Heaven Sometime
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkKK4KeolyQ

15. I'll Never Love Another
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=enZQBRDkQQU

16. So Happy I'll Be
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqDD_KvbjoA

*17. Doin' My Time
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMdYyoF_uOM

*18. Pike County Breakdown
 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjKthlpnP-o

19. Preachin' Prayin' Singin'
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xxa44eER4g

*20. Cora Is Gone
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vtLYK1aWNw

*21. Pain In My Heart
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blG497HwaQE

*22. Roll In My Sweet Baby's Arms
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=riHYkRKXydU

23. Back To The Cross
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7zuog7ra1-Y

*24. Old Salty Dog Blues 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ms2IOc_HA4E

25. Will The Roses Bloom (Where She Lies Sleeping)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgqTLm35j4c

*26. Take Me In A LIfeboat
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtCZPhsfAtI

*27. Farewell Blues
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m259Pg25wdY

28. I'll Just Pretend
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0h8IB33hUf

Happy Pickin',
Jason
Why Don't You Tell Me So - banjo tab
File Size: 406 kb
File Type: jpg
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - guitar tab
File Size: 441 kb
File Type: jpg
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - mandolin tab
File Size: 368 kb
File Type: jpg
Download File

Why Don't You Tell Me So - melody in G
File Size: 418 kb
File Type: jpg
Download File

0 Comments

    Jason's Intermediate Jam Blog 2017 - 2018

    started as Beginner Jam in Jan 2015
    with
    ​Jason Homey

    Picture
    Songs regularly called at Bluegrass Jams and links from Jason's "Song of the Week" emails.  (from Renee)
    ​
    ​

    Songs

    All
    Are You Missing Me
    Auld Lang Syne
    Banks Of The Ohio
    Beautiful Brown Eyes
    Beautiful Star Of Bethlehem
    Big Spike Hammer
    Bill Cheatham
    Blue Ridge Cabin Home
    Canaan's Land
    Cherokee Shuffle
    Cheyenne
    Christmas Carol Progressions
    Christmas Songs
    Clinch Mountain Backstep
    Cry Cry Darlin
    Cryin' Holy
    Devil's Dream
    Dooley
    Down In A Willow Garden
    Down The Road
    East Virginia Blues
    Fireball Mail
    Foggy Mountain Breakdown
    Gathering Flowers From The Hillside
    Gold Rush
    Gold Watch And Chain
    Hand Me Down My Walking Cane
    Head Over Heels
    Homestead On The Farm
    How Mountain Girls Can Love
    I Can't Feel At Home
    I Know You Rider
    In The Pines
    In The Sweet By And By
    I Saw The Light
    John Henry
    Keep On The Sunny Side
    Left Over Biscuits
    Little Cabin Home On The Hill
    Little Darling Pal Of Mine
    Little Maggie
    Little Willie
    Love Of The Mountains
    Love Please Come Home
    Nine Pound Hammer
    Old Home Place
    Old Joe Clark
    O Little Town Of Bethlehem
    On And On
    Over The Waterfall
    Poor Wayfaring Stranger
    Red Haired Boy
    Red Wing
    Reuben
    Roll In My Sweet Baby's Arms
    Roving Gambler
    Sally Goodin
    Salty Dog Blues
    Shuckin' The Corn
    Steel Rails
    Turkey In The Straw
    We'll Meet Again Sweetheart
    Whiskey Before Breakfast
    Why Don't You Tell Me So
    Wildwood Flower
    Wreck Of The Old '97
    X-Hits And B-List Songs Of 2016
    X Music Theory
    X New Song List 2018
    X- Song List 2018
    X-Songs Of The Week Of 2017
    X- The Mercury Sessions
    X-The Original And Great Carter Family

    All of Jason's Songs
    in alphabetical order


    ​Archives

    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017

    RSS Feed

ConTACT US!


ADDRESS:
​Idaho Bluegrass Association
PO Box 6074
Boise, ID 83707

Email

idahobluegrassassociation@gmail.com
Copyright © 2021 IBA.
  • Home
    • About
    • Join Us
    • Donate
    • IBA Newsletter
    • Our Logo
  • Articles & Podcasts
    • Podcasts >
      • ​Jeremy Garrett Interview
      • Keith Reed Interview
      • Jason Homey Interview
      • Becky Smith Interview
      • Marv Quinton Interview
      • Rue Frisbee Interview
      • Donna and Mike Bond Interview
      • Honi Deaton Interview
      • Dennis Stokes Interview
      • Gary Eller Interview
    • Articles >
      • Glen Garrett - The Golden Years
      • Sammie Bush - came to Weiser
      • Mark O’Connor - My History at Weiser
      • Barbara Lamb - Fiddler Extraordinaire
      • Charlie Simmons -The Idaho Bluegrass Association from 1975 to 1985
      • Idaho's 19th century Fiddlers
      • Weiser Fiddle Champions ​ 1950s & 1960s
      • ​Byron Berline
      • Dave Frisbee
      • Weiser Fiddle Champions from 1970s and 80s
      • Megan Lynch Chowning
      • Fiddle Champion ​in 1990s and 2000s
      • Tashina and Tristan Clarridge
    • Snap Shot - Videos from IBA members
  • Events
    • Calendar (BCBB)
    • Open Mic
    • SpringGrass 2023 >
      • Springfest 2022
    • Winterfest
    • IBA Concert Series
    • Virtualgrass
    • Other Bluegrass Events
  • Jam
    • Idaho Jams
    • Jason's Beginner Jam Blog 2021 - 2022
    • Jason's Intermediate Jam Blog 2021 - 2022
    • All of Jason's Songs
    • Old Blogs from Jason >
      • Jason's Beginner Jam Blog 2019 - 2021
      • Jason's Intermediate Jam Blog 2019 - 2021
      • Jason's Beginner Jam Blog 2017 - 2018
      • Jason's Intermediate Jam Blog 2017 - 2018
      • Songs in 2016
  • Camps & Contests
    • Idaho Bluegrass and Banjo Camp
    • Banjo Contest
    • National Oldtime Fiddlers’ Contest
  • Idaho Bands
  • Teachers
  • Classified
  • Links
    • General
    • Learning
    • Specific Instruments